There's a timeless kind of magic here, something that locals know and love along Florida's historic coast. Nestled on Anastasia Island, just a short distance from the beach and nearby Ron Parker Park, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath pool home strikes a balance of coastal living with quiet lakeside relaxation. Solid concrete block construction and metal studs, the home has been thoughtfully updated over the years. Outdoors, the star of the show, a screened saltwater pool invites you to relax while taking in expansive views of Lake Sienna. The dock has been freshly updated with new decking over sturdy marine pilings, providing a perfect place to cast a line, launch a kayak, or watch the evening sky reflected on the water. With egrets & herons as your neighbors, the setting is peaceful yet alive with nature. Inside, bamboo floors stretch through the main living spaces, leading to a kitchen with a spacious suede granite island anchored by modern pendant lighting. All surrounded by custom cabinetry with soft-close drawers, pull-out spice rack, and a pantry with glide-out shelving. Stainless steel appliances include a gas stove with convection oven, microwave drawer, wine refrigerator, and dishwasher making it easy to accomodate both everyday meals and entertaining. A built-in banquette adds a comfortable spot for casual dining or morning coffee. The primary suite features a darling chandelier highlighting the walk-in closet with built-in shelving, drawers and a shoe wall, and the bathroom offers a Jacuzzi tub and a glass shower. Secondary bedrooms also include custom closets for easy organization. Additional features include a new roof in 2020, HVAC system in 2023 and tankless gas water heater in 2024, a deep two-car garage, buried power lines, and a light-touch HOA with just $350 annual fees. Close to the beach, park, St. Augustine Fishing Pier and all the charm of island living, this home offers both comfort and a lifestyle that's easy to love.